Lowest price Plush Toy Cat Toys from $3 to $5 - Compare Prices, Shop & find Cat Toys

Shop, Drag & Drop:

Shop By Brand:

    Bamboo
    Bergan
    Booda
    Cat
    Cat Dancer
    Catnip
    Cats Claws
    Cats With An Attitu..
    Cfa
    Cosmic
    Cosmic Catnip
    Cosmic Pet
    Eats
    Ethical
    Fat Cat
    Go Cat
    Happy Dog
    Hartz
    Kitty Hoots
    Kong
    Lazy Pet
    Multipet
    Omega
    Our Pet's
    Our Pets
    Panic Mouse
    Pet Zone
    Petco
    Petlinks
    Petlinks System
    Petmate
    Petsport
    Petsport Usa
    Petstages
    Savvy Tabby
    Spot
    Various
    Ware
    Zanies

Popular Searches:

    Assortment
    Ball
    Catnip
    Holiday
    Mice
    Plush Toy
    Scratch Post

Shop By Price Range:

$3 - $4
$4 - $5

Shop By Price:

Shop By Color:

SortPrice By:

Lowest Price
Highest Price

Featured Stores:

Plush Toy Cat Toys from DrsFosterSmith.com

Plush Toy Cat Toys from DigitalGiftStore.com

Shop By Store:

    PPE Pet Supplies
    1800PetMeds
    PETCO.com
    DigitalGiftStore..
    GlobalPets.com
    Dog.com
    GregRobert Pet S..
    DrsFosterSmith.c..
    I Love Pets
    PetSmart

    Animal World Net..
    EntirelyPets
    Loyal Pet Suppli..

More Merchants...

Home -> Pets -> Cats -> Cat Toys -> Plush Toy (between $3 to $5) (show all prices?)

1 2 3 4 .. 9 Next »

Drag product images onto the left hand side to create a list.

Showing 1-20 of about 174 results in 0.91782076 seconds

+ large images

Lowest Price / Highest Price

Spot Nips Rainbow Mice Cat Toys (Write A Review)

Ethicals fun Spot Nips Rainbow Mice is the essential toy for any cat owner to collect. Made with fun, bright rainbow colors, these mice are stuffed with catnip to encourage play. Great for interactive play! Assorted colors. Choose 3 or 9 pack.

Like this

$3.02

Share | Shop for more Cat Toys from 'GregRobert Pet Supplies'...

Vo-Toys Kitty Combo Fur and Plush Mice Cat Toy Assorted Colors (Write A Review)

This combo pack offers a variety of texture and eye appealing small toys. Keeps your pet stimulated and active. Watch your pet bat and chase this toy. Small enough to be able to carry it around easily. Assorted colors.

Like this

$3.03

Share | Shop for more Cat Toys from 'GlobalPets.com'...

Vo-Toys Catch as Cat Can with Streamer Cat Toy (Write A Review)

Curling wire with streamers on the end. Stretch the wire out or keep it curl. A tease and play toy you and your cat will enjoy for hours. Simple but very entertaining. Cats love to chase a moving object.

Like this

$3.03

Share | Shop for more Cat Toys from 'GlobalPets.com'...

Vo-Toys Kitty Combo Mice Assorted 7 pack Cat Toy (Write A Review)

Like this

$3.03

Share | Shop for more Cat Toys from 'GlobalPets.com'...

Christmas Pompom Bungee with Teaser Cord Cat Toy (Write A Review)

Christmas Pompom Bungee with Teaser Cord Cat Toy by Ethical is a great Christmas present for your cat. Available in Santa, Mrs. Santa Claus and snowman. Filled with catnip. Makes a great stocking stuffer for your cat. Catnip pom pom bungee teaser toy that is so much fun for cats. Dangle over cats head for hours of fun.. Polyester Fibers, Catnip

Like this

$3.05

Share | Shop for more Cat Toys from 'GregRobert Pet Supplies'...

CFA CATNIP WOOL MOUSE (Write A Review)

Cat toy with catnip

Like this

$3.07

Share | Shop for more Cat Toys from 'I Love Pets'...

NATURAL LADYBUG TEASER (Write A Review)

Developed to appeal to the natural instincts of the indoor cat Ecologically responsible cat toy Ecologically responsible cat toy Materials and dyes come from renewable resources that are naturally found in the environment Developed to appe Fun with a purpose Materials and dyes come from renewable resources that are naturally found in the environme..

Like this

$3.12

Share | Shop for more Cat Toys from 'I Love Pets'...

NATURAL CRINKLE TAIL TEASER (Write A Review)

Materials and dyes come from renewable resources that are naturally found in the environment Ecologically responsible cat toy Fun with a purpose Ecologically responsible cat toy Materials and dyes come from renewable resources that are naturally found in the environment Developed to appe Developed to appeal to the natural instincts of the indoor c..

Like this

$3.12

Share | Shop for more Cat Toys from 'I Love Pets'...

NATURAL MICE (Write A Review)

Ecologically responsible cat toy Materials and dyes come from renewable resources that are naturally found in the environment Developed to appe Developed to appeal to the natural instincts of the indoor cat Ecologically responsible cat toy Materials and dyes come from renewable resources that are naturally found in the environment Fun with a purpo..

Like this

$3.12

Share | Shop for more Cat Toys from 'I Love Pets'...

PINK - Savvy Tabby Camo Teasers (Write A Review)

This fun toy keeps cats entertained for hours, and the trendy camo look will appeal to your pets. Value pack contains six teasers three pink, three green. Trendy camo look will appeal to your cats Each has six long strings that cats love to bat around 6 1/2 toy with bell on 19 3/4 pole with 20 elastic 6 1/2 toy with bell on 19 3/4 pole with 20..

Like this

$3.13

Share | Shop for more Cat Toys from 'PPE Pet Supplies'...

GREEN - Savvy Tabby Camo Teasers (Write A Review)

Like this

$3.13

Share | Shop for more Cat Toys from 'PPE Pet Supplies'...

Crazy Pet Cat Catch-A-Bubble - Catnip Scented - 29ml (Write A Review)

Crazy Pet Cat Catch-A-Bubble Catnip Scented Magic Bubbles Magical long-lasting bubbles scented with catnip are the purr-fect interactive toy for kids of all ages and their cats. Bubbles will stay for hours. Fully safety tested to industry standards. Comes with a wand and fish-shaped bottle for hours of fun.

Like this

$3.23

Share | Shop for more Cat Toys from 'PPE Pet Supplies'...

Velvet Animals Teaser Wand Cat Toy (Write A Review)

Velvet Animals Teaser Wand Cat Toy by Ethical comes in an assortment of little velvet animals that are filled with catnip. Teaser wands are great for lots of interactive play with your cat. The catnip with drive your cat crazy as she or he tries to catch Tiny teasers on a wand are an assortment of velvet animals they have catnip to help entice pack..

Like this 1

$3.24

Share | Shop for more Cat Toys from 'GregRobert Pet Supplies'...

Featherlite Boas Cat Toy - JW (Write A Review)

The Featherlite Boas Cat Toy is just like a Las Vegas boa that you can sprinkle with catnip to put your kitty into overdrive. Great for exercising your cats body and mind while having a great time watching your cat have a blast. Exercise for your cats body and mind. Your pet needs exercise as much as people do Especially sedentary indoor cats. This..

Like this

$3.24

Share | Shop for more Cat Toys from 'GregRobert Pet Supplies'...

Wanderfuls Cat Toy (Write A Review)

This cat toy is simply wanderfuls! You and your cat will spend hours of fun with this magical wand! The crinkling sounds are irresistible and the swaying loops provide plenty of fun-filled play. This cat toy is simply wonderful you and your cat Will spend hours of fun with this enticing magical wand as With any pet toy supervise your pet while pla..

Like this

$3.28

Share | Shop for more Cat Toys from 'GregRobert Pet Supplies'...

CFA CATNIP PORCUPINE (Write A Review)

Cat toy with catnip

Like this

$3.28

Share | Shop for more Cat Toys from 'I Love Pets'...

Vo-Toys Hobnobbers w/ Catnip Cat Toy (Write A Review)

Hangs on any doorknob. Toy dangle as cats swat and play. Catnip inside. Bungee cord effect. Multicolor pom pom. Soft. Great eye catcher. Drive your Cat WildCatnip Filled

Like this

$3.29

Share | Shop for more Cat Toys from 'GlobalPets.com'...

Classic Pet Products Feathers and Balls Kitty Teaser Assorted Colors (Write A Review)

Have fun playing with your cat. Cats love to chase, catch, and batting at toys. The kitty teaser is a fun wand with multicolor feathers and soft plush balls with rattle inside. Wand is approx 20in long does not include string or tooy on the end. Throw out your line and enjoy the fun with your kitty.

Like this

$3.29

Share | Shop for more Cat Toys from 'GlobalPets.com'...

Classic Pet Products CP1 Cat Fishin Cat Toy (Write A Review)

Fishing pole with a cute, bright toy at the end. Throw out your line and watch your cat play.Great Cat ToyBright Colors

Like this

$3.33

Share | Shop for more Cat Toys from 'GlobalPets.com'...

Holiday Hologram Laser Pet Toy for Cats or Dogs (Write A Review)

This fun Holiday Hologram Laser Pet Toy by Ethical is made for cats or dogs and features the image of Santa getting ready to come down the chimney. Cats or dogs will enjoy chasing the image around. Great for use in the dark or night. Popular laser toy. The laser design is santa image getting ready to come down the chimney.

Like this

$3.35

Share | Shop for more Cat Toys from 'GregRobert Pet Supplies'...

Related Categories:

Cat Grooming, Assorted Cat Supplies, Cat Food, Cat Toys, Cat Beds & Furniture, Cat Flea & Tick Treatment, Cat Carriers & Crates, Cat Collars & Leashes, Cat Treats, Cat Healthcare

1 2 3 4 .. 9 Next »

Learn about Cat Toys!
Read Reviews about Cat Toys!

The Wishlist

Facebook users can now use the Facebook Wishlist Application to find the best deal on their own or post some suggested products that friends and family can purchase for birthdays, anniversaries, or any holiday. The Wishlist includes options for creating lists, sharing products with friends and reading reviews on everything from Electronics and Home Decor to Jewelry and Apparel.

Find the lowest prices shopping online with Sortprice.com price comparison. Search, compare prices and shop for products in our categories