Lowest price Plush Toy Cat Toys from $2 to $4 - Compare Prices, Shop & find Cat Toys

Shop, Drag & Drop:

Shop By Brand:

    Booda
    Cat Dancer
    CFA
    Fat Cat
    Kitty Hoots
    Lazy Pet
    Multipet
    Panic Mouse
    Pet Zone
    Petmate
    Petstages

Popular Searches:

    Assortment
    Ball
    Catnip
    Holiday
    Mice
    Plush Toy
    Scratch Post

Shop By Price Range:

$2 - $3

Shop By Price:

Shop By Color:

SortPrice By:

Lowest Price
Highest Price

Featured Stores:

Plush Toy Cat Toys from DigitalGiftStore.com

Plush Toy Cat Toys from DrsFosterSmith.com

Shop By Store:

    PetSmart
    DrsFosterSmith.c..
    I Love Pets
    DigitalGiftStore..
    Dog.com
    PETCO.com
    GlobalPets.com
    GregRobert Pet S..
    PPE Pet Supplies

    EntirelyPets
    Animal World Net..
    Loyal Pet Suppli..
    Discount Cosmeti..
    Pet Nutrition Pr..

More Merchants...

Home -> Pets -> Cats -> Cat Toys -> Plush Toy (between $2 to $4) (show all prices?)

1 2 3 4 .. 15 Next »

Drag product images onto the left hand side to create a list.

Showing 1-20 of about 288 results in 0.956096479 seconds

+ large images

Lowest Price / Highest Price

SPARKLE BALL SET (Write A Review)

Cat toy with rattle

Like this

$2.00

Share | Shop for more Cat Toys from 'I Love Pets'...

JUTE/FEATHER SACK (Write A Review)

Jute is a claw worthy texture your cat will love to get there claws on The sack includes catnip and has colorful feather make this toy even more entertaining

Like this

$2.01

Share | Shop for more Cat Toys from 'I Love Pets'...

Fishbone Teaser with Catnip Cat Toy (Write A Review)

The Fishbone Teaser with Catnip by Ethical comes in an assortment of pastel colors with a fun animal print. This crazy eyed fish is perfect for dangling in front of your playful kitty. Fish is filled with premium catnip to encourage lots of play with your Plush fishbone shaped cat toy in assorted animal print colors. Long teaser cord with bell make..

Like this

$2.02

Share | Shop for more Cat Toys from 'GregRobert Pet Supplies'...

Plush Duck with Feather Tail and Nip Cat Toy (Write A Review)

Your cat will love this adorable duck toy that is filled with catnip inside. Duck is made of plush material and has a feather tail. Great for keeping your cat entertained and out of trouble. Available in an assortment of animal prints. Plush duck shaped cat toy with feather tail. Animal print coloring. Filled with catnip.. Polyester, Cotton Fibers,..

Like this

$2.02

Share | Shop for more Cat Toys from 'GregRobert Pet Supplies'...

Plush Fish with Feather Tail Cat Toy (Write A Review)

This fun and feathery plush fish with a feather tail comes in natural, earth tone colors and is filled with premium catnip that will drive your cat crazy. Fun to toss in the air or chase around the room, this fish is a must have for your cats toy collect Plush fish shaped cat toy with feather toy. Animal print coloring. Filled with catnip.. Polyest..

Like this

$2.02

Share | Shop for more Cat Toys from 'GregRobert Pet Supplies'...

Wiggle Snake Pull Cat Toy (Write A Review)

This wiggle snake pull toy made by Ethical is a fun, bungee cat toy that has a plush head with a bungee in the middle. Made with features and ribbons, your cat will enjoy batting this silly snake around the room. Snake has a ribbon tongue. Plush, ribbon and feather toys in fun snake shapes. Bungee material.. Polyester, Cotton Fibers, Feathers, Catn..

Like this

$2.02

Share | Shop for more Cat Toys from 'GregRobert Pet Supplies'...

Cosmic Catnip Cat Toys - Sock (Write A Review)

An exciting cat toy with the added attraction of catnip.Filled with cosmic catnip your cat will love to bat these around. A traditional cat toy made in the us with real cosmic catnip.. Sock With Catnip In It

Like this

$2.02

Share | Shop for more Cat Toys from 'GregRobert Pet Supplies'...

Spot Nips Long Haired Rattle Mouse Cat Toy (Write A Review)

Spot Nips Long Haired Rattle Mouse Cat Toy by Ethical is a classic fur mouse toy that has a fun rattle noise. Your cat will enjoy swatting and pouncing on this little mouse that rattles with movement. Mouse is 4.5 inches long. This classic fur mouse contains a rattling noise for even more pouncing and swatting fun.

Like this

$2.04

Share | Shop for more Cat Toys from 'GregRobert Pet Supplies'...

Vo-Toys Baby Burlap Balls 2 pack Cat Toy (Write A Review)

Burlap small balls. 2 per pack. Watch your pet bat and chase this toy. Small enough to be able to carry it around easily. Keeps your cat stimulated.

Like this

$2.05

Share | Shop for more Cat Toys from 'GlobalPets.com'...

CREEPS (Write A Review)

It comes in many characters such as tiny fluffy dj44 dr t44 dana young44 amazing larry44 fancy pants james44 Granville thomas44 matlack miner44 the 111 leonard44 little ism44 frank dog44 uncle jesse etc This is a crunchy catnip toy

Like this

$2.07

Share | Shop for more Cat Toys from 'I Love Pets'...

CATMEISTER (Write A Review)

A toy to exercise for your cats body and mind Your cat needs exercise just as much as humans do Especially indoor cats This splendid toy is just the thing for your cat to utilize its natural hunting instincts44 but it must never eat its prey

Like this

$2.07

Share | Shop for more Cat Toys from 'I Love Pets'...

ZERBILS BLISTER CARD (Write A Review)

Watch it spring into action with just one swat this toy Will entertain your pet for hours stimulating its curious side your cat Will enjoy stalking and pouncing on its prey but your pet should never eat the product

Like this

$2.07

Share | Shop for more Cat Toys from 'I Love Pets'...

Spotbrites LED Rainbow Action Cat Ball (Write A Review)

Spotbrites LED Rainbow Action Balls. Motion activated LED Rainbow Ball will entertain pets for hours. Great for night time play, the rainbow ball lights up and flashes LED lights in rainbow colors. Extremely sensitive to movement. Includes on/off switch Turn it on and this fun toy begins to flash in bright colours. After a few moments of in..

Like this

$2.10

Share | Shop for more Cat Toys from 'PPE Pet Supplies'...

CATNIP TERRY HIPPO (Write A Review)

Cat toy loaded with booda ultra premium catnip

Like this

$2.11

Share | Shop for more Cat Toys from 'I Love Pets'...

CATNIP TERRY MONKEY (Write A Review)

Cat toy loaded with booda ultra premium catnip

Like this

$2.11

Share | Shop for more Cat Toys from 'I Love Pets'...

CATNIP TERRY BUNNY (Write A Review)

Cat toy loaded with booda ultra premium catnip

Like this

$2.11

Share | Shop for more Cat Toys from 'I Love Pets'...

CATNIP TERRY MOUSE (Write A Review)

Cat toy loaded with booda ultra premium catnip

Like this

$2.11

Share | Shop for more Cat Toys from 'I Love Pets'...

CATNIP TERRY COW (Write A Review)

Soft to bite yet tough and durable cat toy each cuddly design contains booda ultra premium catnip

Like this

$2.11

Share | Shop for more Cat Toys from 'I Love Pets'...

CATNIP TERRY HEDGEHOG (Write A Review)

Cat toy loaded with booda ultra premium catnip

Like this

$2.11

Share | Shop for more Cat Toys from 'I Love Pets'...

CATNIP TERRY ELEPHANT (Write A Review)

Cat toy loaded with booda ultra premium catnip

Like this

$2.11

Share | Shop for more Cat Toys from 'I Love Pets'...

Related Categories:

Cat Carriers & Crates, Cat Collars & Leashes, Cat Food, Cat Treats, Cat Healthcare, Cat Bowls & Feeding, Cat Flea & Tick Treatment, Cat Toys, Cat Grooming, Cat Beds & Furniture

1 2 3 4 .. 15 Next »

Learn about Cat Toys!
Read Reviews about Cat Toys!

The Wishlist

Facebook users can now use the Facebook Wishlist Application to find the best deal on their own or post some suggested products that friends and family can purchase for birthdays, anniversaries, or any holiday. The Wishlist includes options for creating lists, sharing products with friends and reading reviews on everything from Electronics and Home Decor to Jewelry and Apparel.

Find the lowest prices shopping online with Sortprice.com price comparison. Search, compare prices and shop for products in our categories